OUR FAMILY. YOUR COMMUNITY.
Local connections, lasting relationships.
Family-owned and serving Western Pennsylvania since 1957, McCartney Agency brings generations of local knowledge to every conversation.
A family business with deep local roots.
Susan Kimmel is the daughter of Reed and Ann McCartney. She and Paul purchased the agency in 1997, continuing the family’s commitment to personal service. Today, family members and longtime colleagues help neighbors across Aliquippa, Beaver County, and Greater Pittsburgh navigate their insurance choices.
People you can get to know.
Call our office to reach the right person for your question.
Jeffrey R Bott
Agent
A Rochester, Pennsylvania native, Jeff joined McCartney Insurance in 2000. He is married to Brandi, Paul and Susan Kimmel's eldest daughter, and is proud to be part of the family-owned agency.
Jeff@McCartneyInsurance.com
Amber M Kaufman
Agent
Raised in South Beaver Township, Amber has been part of McCartney Insurance since 1997. As Paul and Susan Kimmel's daughter, she continues the family's tradition of serving the local community.
mccartneyagencyinc@gmail.com
Ethan Bott
Agent
As Jeff Bott's son, Ethan represents the third generation of the family currently working at McCartney Insurance. Since starting at the agency in 2022, he is proud to help carry forward the agency's tradition of personalized service.
mccartneyagencyinc@gmail.com
Paul E Kimmel
Owner
Originally from Ellwood City, Paul and his wife Susan purchased McCartney Insurance in 1997. Together, they continue to oversee the family-owned agency and can be found in the office on Fridays, often accompanied by Ollie, their service dog.
mccartneyagencyinc@gmail.com
Susan A Kimmel
Owner
The daughter of Reed and Ann McCartney, Susan carries on the family's longstanding insurance legacy. She and her husband Paul purchased the agency in 1997 and remain actively involved, visiting the office on Fridays with their service dog, Ollie.
susan@mccartneyinsurance.com
Janet Hudson
A Beaver County native, Janet joined McCartney Insurance in 2000. With more than two decades at the agency, she remains a valued member of the team and its longstanding commitment to serving the local community.
mccartneyagencyinc@gmail.com
Larry Littler
Raised in Crescent Township, Larry joined McCartney Insurance in 1989. With more than three decades at the agency, he brings a wealth of experience and represents an important part of its history in the community.
mccartneyagencyinc@gmail.com





